Shotgun Question

[duck_dude]

I know everyone is going to say go with a gun that fits you well, but what I'm looking for is any negative feedback regarding any of the new waterfowl shotguns. When I say waterfowl shotguns, I'm specifically talking about semi-automatic 12 gauges, 3-1/2" weapons.

Right now I'm shooting a Benelli Super Vinci. It's a nice gun, kills birds, feels nice, but there is one issue; the trigger guard tends to rack my middle finger when shooting heavier loads (1-1/2 oz or larger). The model SV I have is the one where the supposedly fixed this issue by modifying the trigger guard.

So what I want is any negative feedback regarding semi-autos you have. I know there are plenty of people that will say how awesome a gun is, and that's fine, but I just want to hear about issues.

I want to go back to gas operated so I'm looking that the following guns:

Beretta A400 Extreme
Browning Maxus
Remington VersaMax

I'm open to any other suggestions to check out. I'm planning on shooting these guns at the Ahlman's Shooters Roundup this summer.

[emptymag]

Don't shoot over rated 3.5" shells. Problem solved. Your welcome.

[greatwhitehunter3!]

Don't shoot over rated 3.5" shells. Problem solved. Your welcome.

Yes and no. I will not spend $ on 3.5" til late season. Then it's all 3.5" for me.

[duck_dude]

If you want I can start a post about shell selection, but I'm just interested in personal experiences with these guns.

[greatwhitehunter3!]

If you want I can start a post about shell selection, but I'm just interested in personal experiences with these guns.

You'll realize a lot of threads will answer many questions. But sorry for hijacking. I have no experience with any of those guns. Don't buy an SX3 though.

[duck_dude]

It's all good. I've debated the usefulness of 3.5" shells. It's just if I'm going to get a new shotgun, I'd like the option.

[greatwhitehunter3!]

It's all good. I've debated the usefulness of 3.5" shells. It's just if I'm going to get a new shotgun, I'd like the option.

My thoughts exactly.

[gimpfinger]

Get a 870. Sorry someone had to do it.

Sent from the bush outside your bedroom window.

[Nershi]

I bought a gun with 3.5 capabilities thinking I'd want the option. I shot one box of 3.5 waterfowl loads when I bought it. Since then the only 3.5 shell that went through my gun was for a turkey. Too loud, too much kick, too much money, and not neccesary.

Sorry no info on the guns you listed. The only thing I know about gas guns are they are too muzzle heavy for me. Maybe the extra weight from a gas gun will keep it from jumping on you and whacking your finger. I know lot's of guys with Beretta's who are happy.

[emptymag]

I have a SBE II and a M2 and I know what you mean about the finger getting beat up. I've put tape around it before.
I've shot a Maxus at sporting clays and it was a soft shooter. Only thing I dont like is that its just a sx3/gold and I will never own one of those again.