h2ofwlr wrote:Well this is how I look at it. Do/did I agree with Jim on calling it a stupid idea? no. [But if you know Jim, he does not hold back and calls a spade a spade (he did that to a few politicians when on the OHC and ruffled a few feathers as a result) as he was a thorn in their side, rightfully so as some politicians were trying to divert the $ from it's intended purpose]
Do I agree with Bailey's witch hunt on persecuting Jim for his personal opinion? no.
Do I agree with his bashing the MWA because the vast majority did not support the early teal season? no.
But I can understand Jim and other older hunters view point. You need to remember that they grew up on average with 40 day and 4 ducks a day seasons here in MN. 60 day seasons and 6 a day for what is it now, 15 years? That's a 50% jump on days and bag limit. So I get their "when is enough, enough"? mentality.
That being said, I still would have loved to even see a 2 day early teal season as I think that it'd have been fun to try it for certain segment of waterfowl hunters and the species biologically can handle the added hunting pressure.
Now lets get back to reality of what it is: IMHO as long as Tom is Commissioner we will not have an early teal season, or at least not for the next few years. Maybe he'd change his mind, but it'd need to be awfully persuasive. (like 2/3 of the Mn hunters in favor of it and the mistake studies less than 20%). And this past 1.5 years over 2/3 of his 1 on 1 conversations with people are not for the early teal season. And that gentlemen is the heart of the matter and why quit dreaming that it'll change anytime soon.
And bashing, Jim, the MWA, etc will not change the fact that we will not have an early teal season anytime soon.
So quit beating a dead horse as it's getting quite old.
I could maybe understand the enough is enough argument if I saw other states declining the teal seasons, but they don't. Other states have guys who hunted the 30 day seasons as well. As far as landwehr's 1 on 1 conversations who are they with? I have never once been surveyed by the dnr and I have written these guys alot. They don't want to survey guys like me because I disagree with them. They survey who they want to get the results they want. Yes fowler you are right Minnesota will never see a teal season with landwehr because he has a god complex and frankly really doesn't care what guys like me think. If I recall he wrote a pretty sarcastic letter back to somebody on here who dare question his almighty teal decision. I actually did hunt teal Fowler but it was in Wisconsin!
Sent from my Nexus 4 using Tapatalk